Yellow Jackets
I fear stinging, flying insects. For me, they're the worst part of the summer. But I also have a fascination with them.
So when well-meaning students send me links to this blog, I try not to go - but I do. I'm human. I hate wasting time feeling bad over this crap. And the worst part is that on a bad day it can really color my desire to knit or create a design. That sucks, and I have to be strong enough NOT to let it get to me.
This time I stuck a stick in the yellow jacket's nest, and I'm sure I'm going to be stung. Multiple times. Maybe my planets aren't in alignment, maybe I'm sick of being sick, or maybe it's time someone just said, "ENOUGH!" - but this time I decided to try to defend myself a bit. Okay, a lot.
I agree that so many of their posts are funny - but they also seem to have a - dare I say it - vendetta against me. But maybe I'm just being 'Jersey.
At any rate, here's what I wrote. You can see the most recent page about my designs here (this time they had to troll one up from 3 years ago...) [post deleted]
We can also see if they actually let my comment go through. The cruelty and nastiness of folks really amazes me sometimes.
MORE: First of all - thank you to all who are sending so much love. The comments and especially the emails are very appreciated. I wasn't looking for the support (oh, maybe I was...) but I'll gladly accept it.
Most of the links below have been deleted by the YKW blog owners after I published this post Saturday evening. I understand that the blog owners are not responsible for the comments posted to their blog, but they set the tone and have the option to moderate hurtful or inflammatory comments. They bear ultimate responsibility for their blog.
One puzzling aspect is the buddy-buddy tone they take with name designers (read the post on Teva Durham). They seem to want to be associated with the designer - like a school kid who's always insulting you to get attention It's jarring that they claim a first-name-basis with "Teva", but won't tell us their names. Even Mr. Blackwell doesn't hide behind a pseudonym.
It's troubling how they consistently go after their models - especially kids. I think they must not have any of their own.
Nice, Anonymous.
And she reads this. And she is a human being with feelings who tries to keep an open mind and soul so she can design, teach, be a mom, write and pay her mortgage.
Yes it's me.
This was originally a mid-calf white linen dress with a multi colored collar which was changed by the editor so that only the collar was used and many beads were added. It's quite lovely in person, but I agree that the bustier is a really bad styling choice.
There may be some designers who can burn money, but this one needs to pay the mortgage. Three years ago, when this was published, I was happy to be able to keep our heads above water for one more month - in part - with the fee for this. We knit designers do not earn huge money.
Unlike the authors of this blog and most of the posters, I don't hide my identity, I try to be approachable, and I will answer just about any email that anyone sends me.
Why is it such good fun to hurt people, though? In a way it's flattering to know that just about anything I will or have designed will show up here. Some folks will say they like it, most folks will slam it because - well - because I believe they're sycophants.
I know the (nameless) authoresses of this blog will rip me to shreds because I have the nerve to admit that the constant insults about my designs, my mental health, my right to design and especially the insults about my children[post deleted], hurt. Thank god the comments about my "devil children", by one of the blog authors, was deleted. My daughter is old enough to use Google and actually stumbled upon this post when she did a blogger search for my name.
Those of us who try to create are generally pretty sensitive to nasty comments. We try to develop thick skins, but that doesn't always go with a creative spirit.
Like Seinfeld, I'd love to show up at your job and heckle you.
Ironically, it seems the folks who run this blog are also very sensitive to comments toward them - that's a shame. I feel bad that anyone would write nasty things about someone else - it just isn't funny. It may get an immediate chuckle, but it's not the kind of humor that helps us all to grow, to enlarge our souls.
A joke at someone elses' expense is not truly funny, no matter how loud the comedian or their friends laugh.
The folks who write this blog should also know they're infringing on several copyright laws when they consistently publish photos with no credit or link to the original publication attached. I don't believe in censorship, but I do believe in trying to follow copyright laws.
So when well-meaning students send me links to this blog, I try not to go - but I do. I'm human. I hate wasting time feeling bad over this crap. And the worst part is that on a bad day it can really color my desire to knit or create a design. That sucks, and I have to be strong enough NOT to let it get to me.
This time I stuck a stick in the yellow jacket's nest, and I'm sure I'm going to be stung. Multiple times. Maybe my planets aren't in alignment, maybe I'm sick of being sick, or maybe it's time someone just said, "ENOUGH!" - but this time I decided to try to defend myself a bit. Okay, a lot.
I agree that so many of their posts are funny - but they also seem to have a - dare I say it - vendetta against me. But maybe I'm just being 'Jersey.
At any rate, here's what I wrote. You can see the most recent page about my designs here (this time they had to troll one up from 3 years ago...) [post deleted]
We can also see if they actually let my comment go through. The cruelty and nastiness of folks really amazes me sometimes.
MORE: First of all - thank you to all who are sending so much love. The comments and especially the emails are very appreciated. I wasn't looking for the support (oh, maybe I was...) but I'll gladly accept it.
Most of the links below have been deleted by the YKW blog owners after I published this post Saturday evening. I understand that the blog owners are not responsible for the comments posted to their blog, but they set the tone and have the option to moderate hurtful or inflammatory comments. They bear ultimate responsibility for their blog.
One puzzling aspect is the buddy-buddy tone they take with name designers (read the post on Teva Durham). They seem to want to be associated with the designer - like a school kid who's always insulting you to get attention It's jarring that they claim a first-name-basis with "Teva", but won't tell us their names. Even Mr. Blackwell doesn't hide behind a pseudonym.
It's troubling how they consistently go after their models - especially kids. I think they must not have any of their own.
Anonymous said...
The designer was Annie Modesitt, queen of the fugly colors and combo knitting.
God help us all, she writes books too. And she's plotting dsmore Egyptian designs. Check out her blog.
Nice, Anonymous.
And she reads this. And she is a human being with feelings who tries to keep an open mind and soul so she can design, teach, be a mom, write and pay her mortgage.
Yes it's me.
This was originally a mid-calf white linen dress with a multi colored collar which was changed by the editor so that only the collar was used and many beads were added. It's quite lovely in person, but I agree that the bustier is a really bad styling choice. There may be some designers who can burn money, but this one needs to pay the mortgage. Three years ago, when this was published, I was happy to be able to keep our heads above water for one more month - in part - with the fee for this. We knit designers do not earn huge money.
Unlike the authors of this blog and most of the posters, I don't hide my identity, I try to be approachable, and I will answer just about any email that anyone sends me.
Why is it such good fun to hurt people, though? In a way it's flattering to know that just about anything I will or have designed will show up here. Some folks will say they like it, most folks will slam it because - well - because I believe they're sycophants.
I know the (nameless) authoresses of this blog will rip me to shreds because I have the nerve to admit that the constant insults about my designs, my mental health, my right to design and especially the insults about my children[post deleted], hurt. Thank god the comments about my "devil children", by one of the blog authors, was deleted. My daughter is old enough to use Google and actually stumbled upon this post when she did a blogger search for my name.
Those of us who try to create are generally pretty sensitive to nasty comments. We try to develop thick skins, but that doesn't always go with a creative spirit.
Like Seinfeld, I'd love to show up at your job and heckle you.
Ironically, it seems the folks who run this blog are also very sensitive to comments toward them - that's a shame. I feel bad that anyone would write nasty things about someone else - it just isn't funny. It may get an immediate chuckle, but it's not the kind of humor that helps us all to grow, to enlarge our souls.
A joke at someone elses' expense is not truly funny, no matter how loud the comedian or their friends laugh.
The folks who write this blog should also know they're infringing on several copyright laws when they consistently publish photos with no credit or link to the original publication attached. I don't believe in censorship, but I do believe in trying to follow copyright laws.







59 Comments:
Great response Annie! I agree 100% with everything you said. I never go to those sites because everyone has different opinions about designs, but being hurtful to others is WRONG!
Try not to let the small and nasty-minded get you down Annie. You'll never please everyone, so have confidence in what you do and ignore the knockers.
Right on!
Some people get their shits and giggles by making fun of others - people who have nothing in their own lives to make themselves happy.
Annie, let me be the first to say shame on them. I find your blog, and your designs, and your approach to knitting very inspirational. That's why I always check in to see what you've written. And why I always look for your designs. The lesson I had from you has completely changed the way I view my knitting.
This negative site is nothing that has any place in my knitting world, or in my world period. Please don't let it intrude on your world. Your children are lovely creatures (loved them in the fair isle sweaters! what an adorable picture) who show all the creativity and curiousity and respect of their parents.
(Can I just say that those yucky people of the other blog stink?!) Keep up the good work!
Wow, NOT good. I'm so sorry that this hurt you. I read your blog faithfully and clicked to see where your design is and it is gone. So, they must have heard you loud and clear. I think some people have too much time on their hands.
On a lighter note, I just bought your book, "Confessions...." and it is really teaching me about this obsession of mine. I've been a confused knitter and I feel like for the first time I'm actually "getting it!"
Don't listen to a few meanies. You KNOW that you are good. And, you are teaching countless others to BE good. I am one of them and you don't even know you did it! See! Now you go and have a GOOD day and shake them off.
Interesting that they took down the post after your comment. A bit cowardly in my opinion, but nonetheless - Go Annie!
One woman's "fug" is another's "beautious", and if this pair (and their merry band of slammers) feel that their insults constitute a fair assessment of a design, they are deluding themselves.
Methinks they have never designed knits, otherwise they would have a greater appreciation for the time, effort, and dedication that the entire process takes. You keep doing what you do, Annie, and know that there will always be crafty knitters around who seek out your patterns.
Best,
susan
Well, it may interest you to know that every single link you have can no longer be found over at YKW. Hmm...
Hey, my mom's going to see you in Minnesota and she's darn excited about it. I taught her to knit, so she comes to me with questions. She kept me on the phone for about 45 minutes reading over every class/lecture option. You made the final cut, and she's pretty excited...
With respect, I like some of your designs pretty well. But I don't like some of your other designs at all. And I feel the same way about EVERY OTHER DESIGNER out there. I do applaud you for being willing to do new things, and to do old things differently.
You think outside the box. Sometimes I'm with you, sometimes I'm not, but I always wish you well.
Janice, I don't care who loves or hates my designs, or which one's they love or hate. I don't love everything I do, either.
But I do care when folks get their kicks making fun of other folks (especially me..)
As an artist you show your soul to the world through your art and so are vulnerable..some people react.... some are inspired...some rethink..but you have left a footprint , an idea, an inspiration...an appreciation.
A critic has left what... a comment....poof into thin air it goes. ( ...and expletives that show a lack of vocabulary and imagination ) What will be remembered in 5 years !
I always thought my mom made up her way of knitting and at a class in a LYS someone mentioned your book.
It has shown me that this way of knitting is not her invention to drive me crazy but a logical and efficient way to knit. You actually understand what you do and don't just follow instructions, Untill you have this understanding you can't create your own designs easily.
So thank-you for helping me move on from scarf knitting. I'll see you in Toronto where I've signed up for all 3 of your workshops . See you soon Laila
you tell 'em, annie!! to be hurtful just for laughs is pretty pathetic. and to bring the kids into the mix is a no-no. you said it very well indeed!!
I find the outright hostility towards you, Annie, to be quite amazing. It appears you have upset, somehow, the Guardians of all Things Knitting. Perhaps because you are successful? And because you make yourself approachable, unlike most other designers? You have the audacity to promote yourself, something no self-respecting business person would ever do! No, you are just supposed to slip the occasional cryptic reference to your book, or appearance, somehow into the blog and hope someone notices.
You Knit What is not a site I go to very often. Apart from the annoying copyright violations (funny how knitters are very selective in how they approach copyright) I just don't find it funny. The comments are essentially the same, and not at all funny or constructive - rather like blind followers trying to gain the approval of the leader.
I wonder how many critics have ever tried to design something that is not just a stitch pattern added to a scarf? How many have designed what they think is something great, only to find the magazine wants to use a different yarn and suddenly it's not so great?
Comments from YKW and sites like Marilyn's rarely offer things of substance. But they very cleverly promote themselves, while demonising the competition.
Annie,
There are some really nasty and sucky people out there.
Actually, the design that they dissed was the one that first brought you to my attention. I did a double take, read your pattern and decided you were a designer to watch. You have never failed to amaze me with the diversity of your designs.
You, and your work, are different in a sea of the same old same old. I suspect that is why you have such a large following.
Grace
PS I wore the knitted wire and bead bracelet today at our quilt guild's annual show. Everyone admired it, many asked to touch it, some even asked to try it on. (I don't know if it had anything to do with the way I waved my wrist in front of everyone's eyes.) I learned so much from your pattern. Pix of the bracelet and the project progress are on my blog.
I'm an appreciative "lurker"...
Weighing in with a "mean people suck".... BTW- thnx to you- and your site- (i'm a combination knitter-- who didn't KNOW it!) Now my stitches are only twisted when I want them to be! Thnx!
Also- Finally picked up a copy of knitting heretic- today. ;)
Hoping to see you in MI---
PS those who CAN.... KNIT.
Those who can't, criticize.
http://spaces.msn.com/Nottinbutknittin/
HI Annie:
Thank you for writing about this. I too have had my posts deleted by these "women" (I feel that you are too much of a lady for me to use the word I want to use for them) only becaue I have defended pieces that are truly in vogue at the time and that are on the catwalks and streets of Europe at the moment. It seems anyone who has designed and has been published and doesn't see their point of view is censored. It seems to me also that they seem to think it's okay for them to make insulting remarks about children, anorexics and true talent but it seems as is evident in one of their last posts that they didn't appreciate someone calling them obese. Frankly I do not have time for such a hateful site and I wholeheartedly agree with other people who have commented here on your wonderful site that these "women" have never designed a piece of their own and I also am stunned that they are not "women" enough to even have their own work on display. And the fact that they are dismissing copyright laws is truly a sign of just how seedy and wicked they truly are.
Keep on designing and bringing beautiful items into this sometimes ugly world
I've never really understood the appeal of that blog. I think people whose main source of happiness comes from trashing others are in need of therapy! I didn't know they were giving you so much attention - very sorry to hear that. They must be very miserable people (and obviously they can't knit, because they never show their own stuff).
Hoorah Annie for taking a stance against these "women" ( I feel that you are too much of a lady for me to use the word I really want to use to describe these c----!) I too have been censored by these women for making comments about how the patterns that they mock are often seen in vogue, catwalks, etc.... It seems to me that they can dish it but they can't take it themselves as is evident in their latest post where someone was deleted for calling them obese sheep (of course we will never know the true context of the post as they deemed to edit it). Can you blame this person for saying this when anyone with a differing opinion is attacked by their minions. It amazes me that these "women" don't delete comments attacking children or anorexics! It also amuses me that they do not have their own blogs showing their work. Something tells me they fear criticism or as someone else commented here that they don't even know how to knit!!! It comes down to jealousy that they are not designers themselves and that they have not been published. How many of their readers can boast published well selling books..... I doubt any but your good self.
All I can say is kudos for you to speak out for yourself. I believe that your designs speak for themselves and the fact that so much of your work has been published in books and international magazines says much more than these "women's" attempt at gaining notoriety in a niche that they seem to know nothing about. And also funny how they can censor who doesn't follow their grain but they can't follow the law of copyright but were one of the first to complain about the controversy about using the name Stitch and Bitch and how cruel that other company is being. All I can say to them is Pot meet the Kettle
Keep knitting
Well said Annie! Although people have the right to express their opinion, they should also respect people's feelings. I think I've been to that blog once before and although I do think some of the items are on the strange side, some of them I actually liked. It's a matter of opinion. Tearing people down though is not right.
Dear Annie:
I thought I left a very thoughtful, positive comment. I am confused about why you did not allow it to post.
Anyhow, I highly advise you to allow yourself to listen to negative commentary on your designs. I was an art student at one time and this is how I learned to improve my work.
We are just fellow knitters, wanting good designs, and we will happily follow your lead. Just saying.
your work is wonderful and from what I can tell, you are the first one to help others. It seems that in any area when someone is ahead of their time the mediocre need to bring them down. It is outrageous that they not only attack you but your children. I rarely get time to knit, but I yearn to and your blog makes me feel like I am not missing out, and shows me I can still be inspired. Illness makes it harder to deal with such terrible attacks. Don't know what to tell you other than little people with no talent find it necessary to attack others.
Annie,
Just remember, opinions are like @$$#)!(s....everybody has one and that DOESN'T mean they need to be waved around in public.
One way to look at this is that you have achieved a measure of success that makes people who envy your talent and success JEALOUS.
I admire you for doing what you love and making a living.
Ellenknits (somewhere in the Midwest)
I am sorry you found that! I read the blog once but I found it....depressing. Bad karma maybe.
Not to be a brown noser or anything, but your designs are VERY creative--most of them involve a rethinking on unthinking of traditional knitting. Not a tank top--you make a lace corset. Others slap a cable on a boxy jacket--you make a shaped jacket with a two color cable. There are no shortcuts in your designs.
Buck up little camper!
Full Disclosure About Blocking Comments
Yes, I moderate my posts. I was getting spam and there's just so much nastiness out there that I wanted to make my blog a relatively safe place.
It's true that I didn't publish knittykitty's earlier post. I found it to be more of what's on their site (bashing masquerading as objective commentary)
It's my blog - I can post what I want.
But it does make one wonder how brave one can be when they slam other folks but don't identify themselves. I may not agree with some of the blogs that dish designers, but I do have respect for the fact that they own up to their words - they claim them. Someone posting nasty stuff anonymously won't be permitted on my blog. Knittykitty is anonymous - it's a false name and when she identifies herself I'll have more respect for her opinions.
However, posting nice stuff anonymously is just fine...
I also recieved another post - rather neutral - but by someone who was under 18 and just didn't feel right publishing it. There's no age limit here, but I know when I was 17 I would have appreciated (in retrospect) some editing.
Annie, you are such a strong person. I know how much words can hurt, especially when they are on a website read by so many people. I can't even imagine how I would feel if someone said something derogatory about my children. You are a creative inspiring designer. No one loves every designer's designs, but there is always something inspiring in them that can be used in another way. Keep up the great work, you have a lot of supporters.
Annie -- I have learned so much from your book -- you have re-energized my love for knitting. (And having less rowing out is a huge part of that!) My work looks so much better,I knit faster -- it's all good. Don't let that blog get you down.... Amy
Just to say that this is the second time ever I've been moved to leave a comment in a blog.
The very first one was on reading the YKW post on the kids fair isles - I said something to the effect that you were a big grown-up designer & could probably take any criticism on the chin, but describing your children in such a way was completely beyond the pale.
I've never wanted to return there - and on reading your post today, I'm so glad I didn't read it ever again -- as much for avoiding the sheep who comment thoughtlessly, as the garments the blog decides to feature.
I'm so sorry that you've been attacked like this -- but then again, I don't think peope are queuing up to take classes from those self-appointed moderators of taste of the knitting universe.
Good luck to you -- and please show some more designs for kids somewhere. You have such an unusual take on garment construction and colours - of course not everything will be to everyone's taste, but is it not obvious to the great non-designing masses that one can't tell what one likes or dislikes until someone else has the balls to design the bloody thing and put it out there for people to look at?
Annie,
You are a designer making a living and putting food on the table by pulling ideas out of your brain.
You're paying the bills with the fruit of your talent and wits.
Are the girls over at YKW doing the same?
Laugh, my dear. All the way to the bank.
Joan McGowan-Michael who has been slammed publicly for knitting underwear, but whose $ales of the $ame $peak for them$elves.
i suppose it comes down to everyone is entitled to their opinions. however, when those "opinions" become nasty, bashing, seething ugliness (which is alot of what i see on that blog) it starts to smack of jealousy. maybe these "ladies" are jealous that they can't design (or wont?). the only comments i've ever deleted from my blog were spam. i'm not looking for a cheerleading section, honest to god comments. if you don't like something i'm doing, tell me. if you do, tell me. i'm willing to take constructive criticism. meh.
Wow, I had never seen the other blog before...and will not ever go back. Something very creepy about it & the bloggers. You are good people, Annie. I found out the name of my way of knitting because of you. I love your creativity, your strength, and your honesty. If it helps, I don't think that anyone you would care to associate with takes that blog with anything more than a grain of DIRT! Let all the good feeling from those of us who respect you bury their crap. Hang in there!
Goodness. It seems like overreaction all round. In one piece you moan about them censoring you on their blog and then censor them right back on yours! If you think they're coming from the gutter because they make personal points about kids then for goodness sakes don't make personal points back at them about your guess at their lack of kids. Do as you would be done by.
For the record I do like most of your designs, but I think nearly all designers have made some real clunkers their time (especially if they are exciting and different), and it would be a real shame not to be able to talk about that.
Well Francois, perhaps it is overreaction, but I'm just sick of the attacks on myself and other designers and if I can't speak to it on my own blog, then where?
Funny is funny, but personal attacks cross the line. I block - you say censor - personal attacks.
Dearest Annie,
I offer the following quote..."Don't let the bastards get you down!" I don't know who said it first, but it seemed appropriate. Jealousy, in the guise of "constructive" criticism is the "Fugliest" of all!
You will note that these bloggers are not designers. In fact, I have never seen any examples that they knit! Or, if they have an knitting blog elsewhere, they obviously don't want anyone to associate them with YKW? lest they become a target of their own negative karma. And that is what it is. What you throw out into the universe comes home...just think of what they will have to deal with.
Not to worry, dear Annie. The universe takes care of the creative ones! We are the ones who should thank you for sharing your creativity with us!
KNIT ON!
I thought you had some valid complaints. Now that they removed the things that seemed to be offending you, I think you are trying just plain too hard to find something more to complain about. That kid DOES look glazed like a donut. (For the record, I do have kids. I don't think its cruel to say about the kid. Certainly less cruel than having a picture in that get-up recorded for eternity.) Your issue with the Teva Durham post was an incredible reach. Please just enjoy your victory, and have some tea and chocolate and destress or something.
I guess alot of this is the price of fame. And yes darlin' you are famous. And obviously, most designs aren't for everyone. I have a wierd sense of humor and find stuff like that pretty funny, but don't like the personal attacks. So hang in there sister...you are doing a terrific job... we love you...and if someone else doesn't....it's their loss...
I'm getting to the point where i'm DONE with ykw. They're rude to the point where if you admit (admit?!?! why do i have to ADMIT that i like sometihng?) that you like something, they and all the commenters (unless there's another person willing to "admit" they like it too) burn you to death. Don't let 'em bring you down, there's no one on earth who has ultimate judement on anything, and if there were, those two cows running that blog DEFINENTLY wouldn't be it.
I have to say, I have been a big fan of YKW.
Have been.
I have enjoyed looking at the stuff they pick that's ugly. And that's their choice and their right to say that something is ugly. It is equally someone else's right to say it's NOT ugly.
HOWEVER... what bothers me is that it has become a giant ragefest, on everyone's part -- commenters and bloggers alike. When it becomes a personal attack and a catfight, it's not funny or fun any more. Rage and hate breeds more rage and hate. It's a downward spiral.
As an artist, I feel that if you're seriously critiquing what's good and bad about a knit item, rock on. When you're nasty just to be nasty, especially directed personally toward a designer, maybe you should evaluate what's making you so nasty in the first place.
I've found YNW funny at times, although their outraged response to criticism directed at them always amused me. Anyway, they were starting to seem repetitive, and after seeing their cruelty to you & especially your kids...I mean, who elected them arbiters of style & taste, anyway? Way too much power for such corruptibly small minds. They're off my blogroll as of today.
Hi Annie,
Just to say I heard your knitcast interview and really enjoyed it. I've been knitting for over 20 years, and whilst I don't twist stitches, I definitely have a different style - works for me though!
About YKW - although it is perfectly fine to not like designs, and discussions of design elements are not only acceptable but quite often constructive, YKW has never had this balanced approach to knitwear. They have taken things to another level and personal attacks are something else, and bringing children into the mix is absolutely cruel - just not acceptable at all.
Anyway, there's plenty more to be said on the subject, but let us focus on the positive. Being creative, in whatever medium you choose is infinitely more powerful than being destructive.
All the best, Maria J
Hi Annie:
Good for you for calling these self-important critics on their utterly bad and unprofessional behavior. Their blog is the Internet at it's worst.
It's very easy for people like this to sit on the sidelines and take pot shots at someone who is putting her work out there and making a living doing it. Fortunately, the universe has a way of rewarding the hard workers and leaving the naysayers in the muck.
I am a believer in constructive criticism, but this is not that. Most especially, cruelly insulting young children (and adorable ones at that) is squarely beyond the pale. Shame on them.
Keep on keepin' on!
Anne
I think that YKW wanted to be like Threadbared
http://weirdbabe.typepad.com/threadbared/
However, Threadbared is actually funny while YKW is just plain mean. I've stopped reading their blog...I kept waiting for the humor to come through but it never has.
I read YKW. I find them amusing. And, as a matter of fact, that is how I came to find your site. I've purchased (not yet knit) several patterns from you, and I love hearing (reading, duh!) about you and your family.
PRK and KK have a bad case of schadenfreude. You are a great designer and interesting writer. It's hard to say "just ignore them", b/c I am so insecure, if someone did that to me, I would simply withdraw. Keep putting it out there, Annie. Your supporters far outweigh your detractors, even among those who read YKW.
You Knit What has not spared Teva Durham - they've lambasted her designs at least three times that I can recall.
Well said, Annie. And as a fellow designer they have recently ripped, (knit.1 cover sweater-black and white tunic), I feel compelled to join you in some sort of rampage of shutting them down. If for no other reason than it's just illegal to post another publication's finished design on your website. (you CAN post their designs that you've knitting yourself.) Anyway - I love you, I love your designs, and I know what trying to design for a living looks like. In ALL its successes and lapses in judgment.
xoxo
John @ The Point, NYC
Well - I don't read that site and I missed the post since it's been deleted. It's unfortunate that people are mean - especially in the knitting community.
I think you're awesome! After taking your combination knitting class in San Diego, I've become one speedy knitter! Thank you, thank you, thank you!
You're a fantastic teacher and designer - your love for the art shines through. Thank you for putting up with the yuckiness out there and giving us the opportunity to learn from you.
Hey John!
I don't really want them to be shut down. I agree with Teri that they want to be like Threadbear (which is an hysterical site!) and I have laughed at some of their comments (even the one about my Cocoon Sweater - they called it Hurrican Katrina, which was kind of funny...)
I don't even know why this post of theirs hit a nerve with me, I think it was just a matter of feeling SO piled on by them - water on a stone. I don't need for everyone to love my stuff - heck, I don't love all of my stuff - but I would like them to understand the damage they can do. Sadly, we sometimes don't understand how much we can hurt someone until we're hurt ourselves.
I would just like them to be more accountable - either by making themselves known (not hiding behind screen names) or knocking off the personal, scatalogical attacks.
Monkey -
I can't tell you how many times I HAVE felt like withdrawing - but the benefits of putting myself out there so far outweight the digs. I love what I do, I love my students, I love my readers and I'm one of the luckiest people I know!
Go Annie!!! I luv ya and your designs!
Hi Annie,
I always admire the creativity and beauty of your designs.
The soulless minions of orthodoxy (must credit Star Trek: DS9 for the phrase) over at YKW can go buy a sweater if they can't find one they want to knit. And they can "come over here and say that" if they want to get personal.
Your kids are cute.
Cheers,
Robin Melanson
Hear hear John..... I would love to see them closed down as well. I hate hypocrites like them. They have angered me with their comments about both the designs and the models wearing them.
Annie keep at it. It's all jealousy on their part. Let's see who has a t-shirt that lists all of her appearances and has how many books published. Your work speaks for itself. You have remained very dignified in your retorts.
All the best for the future. You deserve all the accolades that you get from reputable sources.
Annie I frequently read your blog and enjoy many of the knits that you have designed and most enjoyed working on one of them for your uncoming book of men knits. I usually don't write comments but to the Fridays post I must. I find it disheartening and ashame that in this day and time we as human being can not simply keep unkind commets to ourselves and may just say to ourselves before speaking that this does not suit my taste. And remeber that if you can't say something nice then don't say anything at all. Remember folks that we live in a world of many different wants, needs and desires. Annie keep doing what you do the way you do it and just know that there will always be nay sayers. Just as there were when you started knitting and some one told you that you were knitting improperly. All the best. Lawrence
I was shocked to see such vitriolic comments about someone who is a genius for thinking outside the norm. I just tried the combined knitting and loved it! I have never liked to purl until I tried it this way. Very cool. Now I visit your blog to see what else is new. Sorry to see there are some empty people out there who spew hatred when they would be better engaged doing charity knitting or building houses for Habitat for Humanity.
Grow up.
Seriously, I know you'll never let this comment through, so I can just speak frankly--this is the neediest and most embarrassing post I've ever read from an adult. You're a professional, your work is subject to critique, even of the satirical and hurtful kind. It's part of putting your work out in the world--if you don't like it, then simply do it for your own pleasure.
It's easy to like reviews as long as they're kind, but one sees the true measure of a person when the reviews are less than kind. The needy, passive-aggressive desperate pleas for attention and sympathy that you deal in on your blog are entirely pathetic. Honestly, if what you're looking for is pity, then mission accomplished.
Again, I know this doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell of actually making it onto your blog as a comment, so consider it a direct communication to you from a disgusted long-term reader.
And, yes, this is anonymous--I don't have any interest in a dialogue with you. I've already wasted too much time even writing this.
I think that, in theory, a blog that points and laughs can be funny. But YKW has failed to be that successful, funny blog, for a variety of reasons. They make things personal - insulting models and designers instead of just saying that certain *designs* are ugly. They don't seem to understand that it's possible to *alter* patterns to suit one's tastes, and often rip to shreds patterns that would be a lot nicer if they just had the imagination to picture it without a certain silly detail or in different colors. They also think they're a lot wittier than they are, and seem to be scared of patterns that look to difficult or time consuming to knit, which always amuses me. And all of these qualities are exacerbated by many of their commenters. (Look at today's post, with the LB Magic Stripes hats, scarves, and socks. See how many commenters seem to think there's something wrong, and even *gross*, about knitting a hat with sport weight yarn? I guess there's no arguing with people who complain about things because they look too challenging, or who don't understand that a hat knit from "sock" yarn really won't make your head smell like feet.)
I still read YKW every so often because I get some sadistic pleasure out of laughing at them. When they complain that something knit in a light weight yarn is too hard or time consuming? When they have one of their very regular freak outs about receiving insults similar to those they dish out? Very funny.
I'm not against criticism. Heck, call me mean, but sometimes I think it's fun to point and laugh. But too often they point at the wrong things (or the wrong aspects of things). While I think cruel anonymous comments are not a good thing, their unwillingness to accept exactly what they serve (essentially, cruel anonymous comments) is incredibly ironic.
What about the childish sophomoric hiding behind "copyright issues", when what you're REALLY saying is, (yet again and again and again)"Oh, poor, poor me...they can't possibly diapprove of my REVOLUTIONARY designs, my risk taking, my hideous colors, it's just that they're MEAN and BITTER and JEALOUS!!!"
Please.
If you cannot believe that people think your designs are bad or ugly,
you're in the wrong business.
Act like a grownup.
I'll throw in my two cents here, too, for what it's worth. (about two cents?) I've thought some of YKW has been funny, some has been too mean-spirited, and I too am amused at how thin-skinned they are when it comes to comments about them. The other thing I find fascinating about the internet is how free people feel to be venomous and negative when they are hiding behind anonymity. In a larger context, it says something sad about humans.
I for one appreciate all the hard work for creating any design. I have not tried to design, simply because I know I can't. I leave it up to people that know how. In my opinion, you are one of those designers that know how. I have been extremely pleased with the few designs of yours that I have finished. It is truly a sign of respect when others buy and create your designs. And when I am complimented on a piece that I have completed or have in progress, I am proud to say that you are the designer.
People that have to knit-pick (no pun intended), over others designs, are expressing their opinion, there's just no accounting for taste :-), but to attack the designers family is lower than low.
Ms. Modesitt, you keep up with your designing and your writing. I do appreciate you and your creativity.
Anonymous attacks are so cowardly. Talent attracts jealousy, and these folks are obviously unable to take what they dish out.
In the end, it will be your patterns we remember.
Cate, who adores the corset pattern and the kind emails you sent me when I got stuck.
I have to say that making fun of bad knitting was funnier when Stitchy McYarnpants started it with her Museum of Kitchy Stitches. I also read YKW and they started off ok, but they just aren't all that funny any more. They're mostly just mean and say the same thing over and over.
At least if someone is going to make fun of you, they can do it in a clever, funny way, right?
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home