Tuesday, May 09, 2006

The Mom I Wanted

I loved my mom very much, she was supportive and always believed that I could do whatever I wanted to do.

But she had a relatively happy childhood as far as kids stuff goes. She was raised in rural WV, her family was pretty well known and - from what I can tell - she was good friends with, or related to, just about everyone at her school.

My own school days weren't as happy. I was odd looking, tall, red-haired, I cried easily and I might as well have had a big red target on my back. I didn't really feel a let-up in the pressure until I went to college, and it seemed to take me years to get past the bullying from Elementary, Jr. High and High School.

Looking back, it seemed that my Elementary school days had set me up to feel like a victim - a rotton feeling - throughout the rest of my school career. This was probably the main reason I left high school before I graduated (high school drop-out with a Masters - that's me!)

Hannah's like me in a lot of ways. But, unlike me, she has a mom who really does believe her when she tells me how much it hurts to have kids make fun of her. I used to come home and tell my mom that kids were laughing at me, calling me names, and she had two pieces of advice;

1) Laugh at it
2) Ignore it

She also told me, "Annette, I know kids, and kids just don't act like that!"

I never felt that she understood.

The principal and teachers at my school in Toledo were also of the 'Suck-It-Up-And-Take-It' school of thought. It was as if my reaction was more important than the initial comment or kick or tripping incident - and I felt responsible as well as victimized.

This is something I don't think about much any more.

If you can get past the crap life is pretty good, and I've been lucky enough to get past a lot of garbage. But Hannah's just wading into it. Like me, she has red hair, she cries easily, she's sensitive (how I grew to hate that word, it seemed to make any amount of abuse my own responsbility - "If only you weren't so sensitive, then the kids wouldn't make fun of you!")

We went through a phase like this a few years ago, but then she got an amazing teacher who would brook NO nonsense in her class and didn't allow any child to treat another disrespectfully. For the most part her school is very good at taking the respect thing VERY seriously, but kids are kids - sometimes cruelty comes easily.

There was a substitute at school today, and stuff got out of hand. Hannah was upset, she called me and wanted me to come and get her. It was the end of the day so I drove over, but the principal, the guidance counselor and most of the teachers were in a meeting when I arrived. I'll have to talk to them later. The school nurse, who is a wonderful woman, spoke with me and said - as if I'd never heard this, "Perhaps Hannah can develop a sense of humor about it..?"

I love this nurse, but I was so frustrated. If you haven't been through this kind of garbage, it's hard to explain how laughing it off only works so well - and usually only when a certain level of maturity is invovled. It's so hard for a kid to find the resources within themselves to laugh when they're the butt of a joke in front of a roomful of peers. I seriously doubt if any adult who offers this advice could withstand what Hannah has so far this year without losing their cool.

I'm actually quite proud of how well Hannah's done for the most part (she calls it "putting on her deaf ears") She certainly keeps her cool better than I did when I was a kid.

But when she tells me, I listen, and I tell her that I understand. And I tell her that it WILL get better. And I tell her that she's kinder and wiser than the kids who make fun of her, but she won't be able to see that for a long time. I tell her that she has every right to be upset, but she also has to decide what she can do that will make the situation better. Everything I wish my mom would have told me.

To my mind, kids are like trees. When they're saplings they can get bent easily, twisted, hurt. Some trees are very strong, some are more supple, some are brittle. If you have an especially tender tree you put posts around it to keep it safe until the trunk is strong. Hannah is a kid who needs a few more posts than the average kid might - but my hope is that if she gets them, she'll grow stronger and self sufficient a bit easier than I did.

I've never believed that making a kid suffer makes them strong.

It seems there's one particular kid who is the most, well, vocal - isn't there always? He's a kid who is a born leader - and isn't 100% sure what to do with his power. I did something my mom would never have done - I called his dad today.

His dad was great, he knew immediately who Hannah was "Oh, Hannah, she's quite a little lady!" and listened with an open mind as I explained the situation (as I understood it.)

We both agreed that if we were in each other's shoes - which we might easily be in as the years go by - we'd both want to know about incidents like this so we could deal with them. It was a good conversation.

Tomorrow I'll go talk to the principal - just to show my face and let him know that - in the spirit of the school respect policy - I hope they'll continue to reinforce the importance of treating others as we'd like to be treated.

I won't tell Hannah to laugh at this stuff - pain isn't funny.

But I will give her a lot of other stuff to laugh about, and help her to create safe places with her friends and here at home so she can grow strong enough to shrug off things like this more easily. Life can be a bitch.

41 Comments:

Blogger Jo said...

Dear Anne
Will you be my MOMMY? I'm so sorry that your Hannah has to go through all this (My Sarah is 19 and has already been there; my Katie is 9 and it's just getting into full swing) but having a Mom who listens to her will be the best gift you can give her on those "bad" days.
One thing that I repeated to my Sarah over and over (and that she now completely understands) is that by the time Hannah finishes high school, she will have made one or two friends that she will keep throughout her life. The rest will blow away like chaff. By the time she is a sophmore in college, she won't give the morons a second thought! Sarah laughs now that she is at a large university, doing exactly what she loves, and the "mean girls" are either married, pregnant or working at Chiles!
Kisses and hugs for Hannah! We DO understand!

May 09, 2006 10:02 PM  
Blogger Cathy said...

Nodded all the way thru in recognition. Good for you. What a gift you are giving to Hannah.

May 09, 2006 11:14 PM  
Blogger woolywoman said...

Oh, man. I wish you'd been my mom. I spent my whole life before college having a big old target on my back. Yep, it's not funny. I'm glad Hannah has you there for her.

May 09, 2006 11:15 PM  
Blogger S.B. Naas said...

Annie,
I feel for Hannah, and i feel for you. I was also the kid that everyone else made fun of. There were only ever 12 of us in my class... at the most. I don'tn think that the teachers put up with much, but kids are by nature cruel, and they will do what they will. I applaud you for knowing that Hannah is telling the truth and listening. I am also glad to know that you are willing to talk to the ring leader's dad so that he can have a hand in it. You are right, that someday when Hannah looks back, she will see that these horrible and frustrating experiences have made her a better person. They can twist you, but they can also give you a sense of caring and capacity for love that no one else gets. I will be praying for you both.
Sharah (& and her non- knitting bf)

May 10, 2006 12:27 AM  
Blogger Kim Werker said...

Yes, it can be. Hannah's lucky you're her mom. On a day when I've had to deal with bullies myself, even I'm happier and feel safe having read what you wrote.

(I've never commented before, but I love your blog and your work.)

May 10, 2006 1:50 AM  
Anonymous Sally said...

My 5-year-old's a sensitive soul, too, and takes very much to heart the random meanness and cruelty that her some of her classmates dish out. I try to be sympathetic, but I've also given her that "if only you weren't *so* sensitive about it..." line a few times. It's true enough, but she can't help how she is, and such advice doesn't teach her in any way how to better deal with abuse next time. As you say, some "saplings" need more support than others to become strong. I need to rethink a bit how I react to my girl's tales of playground woe. Thanks for the thought-provoking post!

May 10, 2006 4:11 AM  
Blogger Nick said...

Isn't there an anti-bullying protocol in her school? That would be something to hold on to in your talks. And since everybody is talking about 'a better society' with more understanding and solidarity, why not start implementing those points where it matters....at school?

May 10, 2006 4:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I, too, have red frizzy hair, extremely sensitive, used to cry at the drop of a hat - which made me more shy -what a viscious circle it was then. My mom never understood either. I'm 45 and last year decided it was ok to have red hair. I'm feeling pretty great that I have hair when I look at all the bald people who used to make fun of me! Thanks for sharing.

May 10, 2006 5:37 AM  
Blogger Yarngirl said...

OMG. You are a kickin MOm!!! I wish my mom had done that for me, too! One suggestion - when you talk to that principal, I would let him know what the school nurse said to you. I am a para at a school and what happened to you, Hannah, me and tons of other kids is now termed "bullying" and it is unacceptable behavior. Even if it was meant in a "fun" way. So she should have to develop a sense of humor about something that is clearly NOT FUNNY. And we are not permitted to suggest such things to any child or parent at our school. And why should she have to accomodate and accept someone else's bad behavior????? What the heck to people think these days? I'm just so happy for her and you - you are really giving her the support and unconditional love that we all wish we could have! Happy Mother's Day!!!

May 10, 2006 5:40 AM  
Blogger larissa said...

Annie, that was such a beautiful and heartfelt post, I just had to leave a comment. You've been able to offer Hannah so much support; if only other parents could remember how painful childhood can be. I would certainly agree that if you can get through school, then things absolutely get so much better. I know Hannah will appreciate your support down the track.

May 10, 2006 6:14 AM  
Blogger Liz K. said...

Annie, I got the relentless teasing from my brother, and never understood why I needed to change, to be less senstitive. Wasn't he the one being mean?

I worry about what I will tell my daughter, my very own Annie, about teasing, and how I will handle it. Now, your approach will be my primer.

God bless you, Annie. You said just the right thing.

May 10, 2006 7:58 AM  
Blogger Cheryl said...

Annie this post made me cry. Yes tell Hannah it will hurt, but one has to plow through it and be the bigger person. I have a 9 year old son, and it's just starting on his end. I know he has to learn to protect himself, buts it so hard to not be the mother hen and just keep him safe.

May 10, 2006 8:25 AM  
Anonymous Deb said...

Oh my-I am a teacher (have been for 25 years!) and the one constant is that kids tend to find a child who can be targeted and then relentlessly harrass said child. I like to believe I am in the category of "every child has worth and every child is safe" in my classroom (and parents have commented on improvements in their child's self esteem in my room)-I encourage kids to celebrate their differences, by acting sort of "unique" myself. I think we all need "life coaches"-and I think your Hannah has found one-you. I wonder if it is time to start a "girls are special" club at school, with Hannah being a part of that, and any bullying means the bully has to leave?

May 10, 2006 8:27 AM  
Anonymous Marlana "EnigLdy" said...

You're a classy Mom. I raised my children to be a friend to the kid being picked on. My daughter welcomed this attitude and was always the friend to pick you up. Luckily, they now allow you to press assault charges against bullies. I wouldn't hesitate to pull out the ace of spades if things escalate to hands-on abuse. I remember when my son came home from school and told us that "they" were calling him fat. My dear husband told him to ask if they wanted an @zz whippin' from a fat kid. Funny, we never heard another peep. It may not be the best defense but humor must have worked. I wish you the best through all of this. It is hard to send them to school when you know they're afraid of how their day will turn out. Hugs to you and Hannah. I hope she can hold her chin high and show them who is the boss.

May 10, 2006 8:36 AM  
Blogger Claudia said...

Annie - Hannah is very lucky to have you as a mom. Wonderful blog entry!

May 10, 2006 9:35 AM  
Blogger cursingmama said...

I absolutely love your tree analogy, it is so very true. Hannah is lucky to have you as her mother. How wonderful to hear that the father of the other child was open to discussing the behavior; too often our kids can be different people outside of our eyesight and as parents we need to be willing to listen to other peoples observations and experiences without being defensive. I hope that this will be a turning point for Hannah.

May 10, 2006 9:52 AM  
Blogger DianeS said...

How familiar (unfortunately). I was picked on in jr.high, as was my daughter. I would tell her not to let them see her cry...hold it in however you can (by laughing it off, ignoring them, moving, whatever worked in that day's situation). When she got home with us, she could talk it out, cry, whatever she needed. One of the things that seemed to work for her is realizing that those bullies were actually kind of pitiful that they needed to make someone feel bad to make themselves feel better. My daughter is now 21, successfully working on her BS in accounting, teaches horseback riding lessons and has learned that she is in control of what she does and how she feels. What a young woman to be proud of!

Oh, and red hair? Mine used to bleach out red in the summer and both of us like to (on occassion) get that box of dye and go red!

May 10, 2006 10:16 AM  
Blogger Gina said...

Good for you and good for that father. I can't understand it when parents won't listen to "bad news" about their kids. What a great example you are setting for Hannah -- not to mention maybe some adults!

May 10, 2006 10:42 AM  
Anonymous Marie said...

You sound like a wonderful mommy - like the one I wish I had. I was also picked in school. I was just talking with a psychologist about how I wish I hadn't cared so much about what other people thought of me when I was younger, and she said children aren't equipped to do that - so you are absolutely right: the advice to "ignore it" is absolutely WRONG! I hope I can keep your example in mind when I have kids in school someday.

May 10, 2006 11:13 AM  
Blogger Lisa said...

So very well said. I got picked on a lot in school, and you're so right...it's not funny. Growing up can be painful and I applaud you for doing the right thing, not the easy thing all the time but the right thing. Big hugs to Hannah.

May 10, 2006 11:22 AM  
Anonymous Liz said...

Bravo Annie! As another redhead who was not the most popular person I remember how hard being a kid is. You handled the situation perfectly. Hopefully I'll never have to use this, but it's a great example to file away.

May 10, 2006 11:31 AM  
Blogger Mandy said...

What wonderful advice to your daughter, Annie. It must be so hard for you to go through this again, through her. I'm 31 now, and when my Mom talks about the BS I got in school 20+ years ago, she is truly terrible to behold - she's 7 inches shorter than me and slim, but she looks like Mama Bear! I didn't realize at the time how much it hurt her to see me suffer, and to feel unable to protect me. I don't know how I'll handle it if my husband and I have kids and they go through this... they probably will, too, we were both big geeks. I guess the very most important thing is to always feel loved at home, that sure makes up for a hell of a lot. Sounds like your kids are very well taken care of in that respect. :)

May 10, 2006 11:41 AM  
Blogger Jena the yarn harpy said...

I applaud you for understanding and standing up for your daughter. I also grew up hating the word "sensitive"... to this day, my family (parents, brother) still doesn't understand that I'm *crying* because they have *hurt my feelings*. I don't doubt that Hannah will grow up a much stronger person for having such a wonderful support system.

May 10, 2006 11:57 AM  
Anonymous Cherrie said...

Wow, that was a horrible flashback to my grammar school days. Luckily my parents were my biggest cheerleaders and didn't insist that school years were the best part of life. I hope my daughter never gets bullied, but I'll know what to say if she does.

May 10, 2006 12:19 PM  
Blogger kendall said...

Thank you for sharing your story. It is much like mine, and it is nice to have someone to relate to. I am going to have my son read it because you are saying so many of the things I say to him. He has a difficult time as well. I keep telling him that it does get better as we get older. Somehow it seems to be easier to avoid the bullies as an adult.

May 10, 2006 12:42 PM  
Blogger Dawn said...

I two am a senstive person. I would like to suggest a good website with several wonderful books about this topic. It is http://www.hsperson.com/ on this website the author Elaine Aron discusses the Highly Sensitive person. The book I have, the Highly Sensitive Person, talks about how wonderful being sensitive is! Yes, we get picked on...but we can walk into a room and know what someone needs to be more comfortable. We are more caring etc. If you or your family have these tendences I think it would be so good for you to check out the books. I found them so enlightening to who I am as a person and helpful for my self-esteem.

May 10, 2006 1:08 PM  
Anonymous LisaK said...

Maybe in about twenty years it won't hurt so much.... but it isn't funny and never will be.

My brother was allowed to tease the heck out of me for many years. I still don't like him. I think we could have had a better relationship if it would have been stopped. He is six years older. It's not like it was "even".

He is still a bit of a bully.

I don't remember too much teasing in school. I probably blocked it out.

May 10, 2006 1:28 PM  
Blogger cindy said...

My daughter was bullied in middle school and we handled it in a similar way. Kudos to you for addressing this issue with the parent. Perhaps his child will learn not to bully others.

May 10, 2006 2:03 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sometimes it helps to have a comeback handy, something ready to say. My 2nd grade teacher taught our class this:

"It's sad that you feel so bad about yourself that you need to put other people down to make yourself feel better! I feel sorry for you." -- and to keep repeating some variation of that, like "You're only saying that because it makes you feel better to put someone down, that's a shame."

She also taught us "Nobody can make you feel inferior without your consent." (Eleanor Roosevelt) That didn't make much sense to me in 2nd grade but it stuck in my brain and I eventually got it.

May 10, 2006 2:04 PM  
Anonymous Anna-Liza said...

We seem to have had similar childhoods, and similar attitudes in our mothers. Mine is a wonderful person who had a totally different childhood experience from mine, and really didn't get why I was so unhappy at school. I actually loved learning and my teachers, but just hated recess and any other time kids were relatively unsupervised.

I made sure to tell my older kids "it really does get better when you're older" and also did my best to help them understand that "some people are just like that". (They are now adults). I like what you wrote and hope to keep it in mind as my youngest two go through their own "stuff". My third is about to start Kindergarten, and the youngest is two.

I second the Aron books, by the way. They really helped me understand why I am so sensitive and how to deal with the less sensitive, and also how to help my sensitive children. "Sensitive" -- what is wrong with being sensitive?

May 10, 2006 5:01 PM  
Anonymous Melise said...

When we were looking at schools for our kids, one of the heads of school (yes, I live in Los Angeles, no such thing as sending our kids to public schools...) said something that I will never forget. She said that if you find a school that has "self esteem" as a class, to run the other direction, because self-esteem issues run throughout every class and every moment at school. We were so lucky to find the school we ended up at...a small school, and expensive, but thank god my ex can afford it, because self-esteem is built into everything, and my sons believe that they can fly the moon. Good luck to Hannah, and tell her that although things may not get better when she gets older, it does get easier to live with them...

May 10, 2006 6:16 PM  
Blogger Isabel said...

You are such an awesome Mom. Hannah has a head start on most kids for this fact alone. The only thing that helped me with bullying (or not even bullying, but being the outsider) was my Mom's heartfelt belief that our family wasn't just different on the outside, but different on the inside. She reaffirmed that we were different and that that was okay: if other people never understood us that would still be okay. It gave me perspective, some distance from the comments and behaviour of other kids. If you're a bright kid, the farther you go in life the more you will find yourself working with or studying with bright people from all walks of life. It's only in the first years of school that you're with the microcosm of society.

May 10, 2006 8:10 PM  
Blogger Hari said...

Seriously, you are my hero, and how many ways can I count?

I also love how you compare kids to trees.

May 10, 2006 9:16 PM  
Blogger Anita said...

You're an awesome mom! Thanks for speaking to the other kid's dad first--there are so many parents that won't do that, which is really a shame. The best way for us to teach our children to treat each other with civility and respect is to model it for them with others.

May 10, 2006 9:22 PM  
Blogger Margarita said...

Annie,

Not only do we have the same birthday but we had the same childhood. Bravo to you for standing up for Hannah like that, it's so important for kids to see that!

Margarita

May 11, 2006 2:17 AM  
Anonymous marietta said...

i have so been there!!! janis always told me to ignore it too but she also knew that that wasn't the only way to get through it - i sometimes think that is why she encouraged me to go into theatre...:) encouraged the whole artistic side (is that what happens to us too sensitive types? :) the arts?

May 11, 2006 9:28 PM  
Blogger HolyKnitter said...

Annie, I appreciate your struggle and Hannah's, and my own personal experiences with similar situations still resonate painfullly sometimes, years later.

It occurs to me that the single-most helpful coping strategy that my (amazing and wonderful) mother shared with me may also help Hannah. Nevermind some clever comeback in the moment, or trying to ignore it and not react. Instead, imagine bumping into them at your twenty-fifth high school reunion. Where will you be in your life, and where will they be? What you might say to these bullies then?

Learning how to think in this big-picture way, looking forward into my hopeful future rather than miring myself into a dreadful present was one of the best gifts my mother ever gave me.

My personal favorite revenge remark to a bully: "Oh, Katie, you look just like your mother!" (In her case, defintely not a compliment!)

Sadly, I will never get to tell Katie that she looks like her mother, or use any of the other great zingers that got me through middle school. The group of girls who made my seventh and eighth grade years absolutely miserable failed our freshman year of high school, had to repeat the year at another school, and by the time they would have graduated, most had dropped out of school to care for the results of their unwanted pregnancies! Clearly, being the top of the middle school totem pole didn't take them very far. I don't wish these girls' fates on anyone, but may Hannah's bullies learn that pride goes before a fall!

May 11, 2006 11:01 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Annie - You are so fantastic and handled this situation just the way it should be handled. Children will grow up to be good people if they learn to take responsibility for their actions when they are young. It hink it's especially difficult for young ladies and "sensitivity" is a gift, not a curse - it should be nurtured. Way to go, Mom!

May 12, 2006 12:52 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

One thing that really helped at my school was a peer support program. Responsible older kids mentored younger kids once a week. The great thing about the training programme which everyone had to go through in yr 7 and y9 was watching potiential bullies gain understanding and compassion for other kids. the programme also gave kids coping skills for dealing with bullies, dealling with them compassionatly setting boundaries with out reatiliating.

May 16, 2006 4:10 AM  
Anonymous Elise Hiller said...

Annie: I was so struck by your words today. We have been living the same life only my son is 13 and I feel like I have been there and done that. It does get better, and sometimes it gets a little worse. One thing that seems to have helped my son (and therefore us) is to do just what you are doing....going into the school and letting administrators and teachers know what is happening. It may not have fixed the situation, but it certainly made my son feel a lot better because he could see us supporting him in addition to all the verbal support we provide.

In the end, he is in a different school district (long story) but things are better. Sometimes it is not just that the other children are cruel (they are) but we found that insensitive teachers and/or principals also contributed to our son's unhappiness in school.

It is hard to tell a child to laugh it off...it just is not that easy, especially when you have a sensitive child to begin with.

I can only talk about the pain I felt when my son was so unhappy. I would take a thousand barbs myself if it would lessen his pain...but there is always light at the end of the tunnel.

Keep up the great work.
Elise

May 16, 2006 12:43 PM  
Blogger stephanie said...

I'm in tears after reading this. I was treated awfully in grade school as well and it was always me that was expected to change (it was always my fault, of course;I should have just ignored it). The adults around me felt so strongly on this point that I was the one sent to the school psychologist - not the bullies. My parents always seeming to take the school's side when I'd finally had enough and completely lost it didn't help.

It left a mark, but I didn't realize how deep till a few years ago. I had genetic screening at 31 and when it came out normal, I had this major epiphany that no, there isn't something inherently wrong with me that caused people to treat me like that.

If I'd had parents like you... If only the bullies had had parents like the father you spoke to. I at least learned, like you, what not to do.

May 22, 2006 8:27 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home