At Long Last - I Give You Shiloh!
This kitten gets lot of Gerry time - they're both loving it - and Hannah is constantly with Mr. S. Max and I are on the short end of the stick when it comes to Shiloh Time.
I pet it a lot - when we let it run around the living room in the evening it generally runs over to me and hangs out. It must really like that antibiotic medicine.
All in all, it seems that Shiloh is a very good addition to our family. We were missing an orange cat - and as soon as Gigi comes around, she'll REALLY appreciate another warm body to snuggle up with this Minnesota Winter!
Business CARDS
I've needed cards for more than a year now, but I kept putting it off. I get bored with business cards, by the time I run through a box I'm sick to death of them.
It's pretty great, too, to have business cards with my OWN designs on them!
Professional Teaching Vent
(almost moving into Rant?)
This has been on my mind lately - I've been trying to think of the best way to approach this sensitive topic. It's hard to write honestly and objectively about what one does for a living, but a few things have come up that I want to address on the blog.
As knitting teachers, we have no union or guild. There are guilds of knitwear designers in Canada and the US, but they don't cover what I need addressed.
I think we need to have a standard contract as a jumping off point for individual negotiation; a minimum amount that shops should expect to pay, and a minimum of travel expenses that need to be covered.
In exchange, we provide the shop or venue with quality teaching which will bring in students. As with any well-written contract, it would benefit BOTH parties.
I feel it's important to set a criteria of what's expected from teachers; and what teachers can expect from the venues where they teach. I make my own teaching requirements public - I have nothing to hide there - and then I negotiate privately with each shop depending on their individual needs, changing my standard letter of agreement as necessary.
I am NOT a one-size-fits-all kind of teacher, I believe we're ALL special cases - venues & instructors alike.
Math
In traveling to teach, there are expenses, and there is income. I'm upfront with my expenses, and expect the shops where I teach to help me offset these expenses so I'm not cutting into my income as a teacher.Let's visit my life as if it were a word problem (click on chart to see the math);
Scenario OneAs you can see, the best scenario financially (with the least investment by the shop) is #3, but that involves shops being open to 'sharing' me (not all are - which makes me sad. There's lots of me to go around, folks...)
Happy, owner of Happy's Yarn Shop, wants to hire Annie to teach four 3-hour knitting classes over a 2 day period. She wants her to teach 2 classes each on Saturday & Sunday. Happy's shop isn't large, so she arranges to use the vacant office next door to hold the classes so she can have up to 28 people in each class (total participants, 90). Her gross income is $6,550, netting her $3,890 after expenses.
Scenario Two
Happy wants to offer the same classes as above, but can't rent an extra space. She can accommodate 14 people in a class in the back of her shop (avg 12 per class), so in this case her book & yarn sales are less and the gross income is reduced to $3,680. Her expenses are also reduced to $1,760, netting her a $1,920 profit.
Scenario Three
Same as scenario 2, but now Happy's joined with two other shops in the same medium sized city and has reduced the transportation expenses by 2/3, and loses one night of accommodation costs to another shop. But a car has to be rented so this adds a bit to the travel expenses. Total expenses = $1,490, netting her a $2,190 profit.
Exclusive? Pas moi!
I don't like exclusives, I won't agree to them unless a shop 'fills up my dance card' and leaves no space for someone else to hire me. If a venue wants me to agree to teach exclusively with them alone, they have to either offest the money I would lose, or give me enough classes to make it worthwhile.
But I feel exclusives are bad for another reason. When I teach at several shops in a city, there's a good chance that some folks from Shop A, who usually don't visit Shop B, will find their way over there if that class fits their schedule better.
It's true that Shop A has "lost" that customer for one class, but there's also a very good chance that other customers from Shop B are 'discovering' Shop A in the same manner.
The buzz involved in a few shops publicizing my visit helps fill ALL the classes. A win/win.
So - why this rant?
The reason this has come up is lately I've had some wonderfully full, exceptional classes - and I also had two scheduling events that throw a little worm of doubt into my bushel-basket of fall classes.
Worm #1
I recently heard from TNNA that they haven't accepted any of my classes for the Long Beach show in January. I'm saddened by this. I love to go to TNNA, but I can't really afford to go if I'm not teaching.
I could set up some teaching gigs in the Long Beach / LA area - I probably should - but I'm confused by the decision because my last few classes at TNNA have sold out VERY quickly, and were very well received. I wrote asking if there were something I could do to help my classes for the next TNNA be favorably considered, but haven't heard back yet.
My classes aren't sponsored, though - meaning, I have no larger entity who's offered to cover my expenses for the class - so all of the funds would have to come from TNNA. Half my classes were sponsored last time, which makes it easier for TNNA - they have a budget, too!
Worm #2
A venue would like to hire me to teach a few days after a large knitting conference. Since I have no books coming out this year, and there's a good chance I may not be teaching at this conference (I'll find out definitely late in the year), I'll be covering my own airfare if I go.
This particular venue hires a lot of 'name' knit teachers for a sort of mini-conference, taking advantage of the fact that they're in the area for the bigger conference - which is a very wise move.
The venue anticipates that the teachers will have someone else covering most of their travel costs, so their travel allowance is low. They'll also only cover half of a room per night (forcing a teacher to either share a room, or cover the balance for a single.)
So between the low airfare & the extra $ for a single, I could be out at least $400 if I'm at this venue for 4 days teaching. But I could find a way to make it work financially if I could set up other teaching engagements and split the travel expenses.
Unfortunately, this venue also insists that I not teach the classes I teach for them anywhere within a 300 mile radius for 30 days. This would include EVERY city of any size in the state.
So basically they want me to teach for them, for them alone, and they won't fully cover the expenses that are required. I even offered to stay at a different, cheaper hotel so I could sleep alone - but no go, they want all of us in the same place.
They sent me a list of teachers who have agreed so far - I know many of them and like all of them - and I'm glad they they're in a situation where their airfare is covered and they don't need to sleep alone.
So, sadly, I had to tell this venue "No." I would so love to do this, but not enough to agree to terms which are so one sided. I've been told by them that they can't work out individual contracts with each teacher because it would 'make them nuts.'
Teachers ARE all individuals
We have different needs, airfares, travel requirements.
Sometimes - NOT often - I feel that it's hard to get across that I'm not just a teacher, but a HUMAN BEING. When policies get in the way, humans have to deal with each other on a one-to-one basis.
I treat every venue where I teach individually, working out specific items in the contract as the venues require it. Yes, it may take more effort, but that's part of my job. And in the long run good communication/contracts are much less work.
Dealing with teachers based on their individual needs and requirements is no more work that treating a room of 30 students as 30 humans, helping each one with their individual problems as they arise. Not giving each student a private lesson, but explaining things in several ways so that every student can 'get it.'
One size does NOT fit all - isn't that one of the reasons why we knit?









20 Comments:
That sounds really frustrating and I totally see your position and why you might find it hard. I'm also someone who tends to over think rejection and turn it back on myself and I hope you won't let it get to you. Everyone will have good and bad classes but you are a great teacher.
Personally, I've become very leery of dealing with small businesses. I've had some really great experiences but I've also had some very bad ones. I just hate that feeling like someone is taking advantage of a situation without giving consideration to the other parties involved. I have to give you a lot of credit for managing so many of these small business interactions.
This is such a thoughtful post..thank you. Both my husband and I have done a lot of teaching. (not so much knitting, but lots of other fields, including spinning.) I think people DO forget that teachers are human. We don't live in classroom filing cabinets, and we eat, sleep, and need down time like everyone else. You are making reasonable decisions regarding that venue' exclusivity clause. Don't they realize that the exclusivity clause makes YOU nuts? (never mind not being cost effective.) Maybe this year, if the shops near TNNA don't work out, you can sit things out and design at home, cooking up new and exciting classes and ideas for the next time around at TNNA. Good luck with this--I think you're right!
Well, I just have a thought to share about your worm #2. It's obviously your rant and I expect that you were mostly letting out some steam, but maybe it could add a little perspective.
The organizers are people too, and maybe they are understaffed or have an overly demanding boss and working out individual contracts would overwhelm them.
One size doesn't fit all, and that applies to everything. Teachers, organizers, events, and engagements all have different restrictions and requirements. Sometimes the job just doesn't fit and it's in everyone's best interest if the first person who notices just says no. I don't see it as something to regret, it just means that you will be doing something more fitting with your time.
Dear Annie: Just a thought. Quilting teachers, I think, have some kind of standard contract, or standardized contract, they use when travelling to guilds. Alex Anderson might know something about this. Can knitting teachers do similar things?
Pattie in San Francisco
Well, actually, Scenario 1 is best for the shop in that $3890>2190. However, point taken!
I think alot of the teachers are indeed probably already in town for the other event, or in the case of TNNA are being sponsored by a publisher, yarn company, second cousin once removed, whatever, so that TNNA probably has a set figure and can't exceed it - or go over budget.
As for the guild or the standardized contracts, I ponder this. The closest I can think of is the Embroidery Guild. They have a magazine and resources for embroidery teachers - Aprize is the magazine. I used the EGA materials for judging, and they are most excellent indeed, but haven't used the teaching stuff since I don't teach so I don't know what they have in their teaching materials. They do have in their forms section sample contracts for their member guilds to use in HIRING teachers.
And, speaking of which - whatcha'll doing the first weekend in May? Because if you don't mind I was thinking of suggesting you to MD S&W for workshops next year. Of course, I was also thinking of suggesting to the sheepdog lady that perhaps some year we might do a view of herding involving more than BCs, but that's only because poodle 2 is actually going sheepherding on Monday. 8-)
Hmmm, well, that didn't work! If this turns out to be a double post, delete one of them!
I don't know how you keep all of this straight, and schedule all of these trips, and then on top of it, teach with such joy and grace! I truly admire you for doing this; I wish it could be easier... It sounds like maybe some other crafts have standard contracts; I wonder to what agency one could go to advocate for something like that for knitters? As a teacher, I'm totally with you about the people are individuals thing -- there's definitely a middle ground between treating everyone the same, and having to reinvent the wheel with each student; you'd think the stores could find that middle ground when writing contracts. Good luck!
Annie-just got my new Vogue and your Russian Roses was so worth the sore fingers! I love the editors reference to real knitters being able to tackle an AM pattern.
Real designers,knitters,teachers need to be compensated fairly and a uniform system would be helpful.
Knitting is not a competive sport. We all want access to our brilliant gurus! Love you and your work!
Seems to me the venue in worm 2 is expecting preferential treatment. They are expecting to get your services for far less than what another venue would pay in the same circumstances. I find it remarkable that they would take advantage of the preceding knitting conference (expecting teachers to get ? of their travel expenses from the large conference) but are unwilling to let other venues/shops take advantage of their mini-conference. Seems really unfair & selfish!
You are being very reasonable. I used to do a lot of travel and teaching (not knitting, another craft) and your requirements are the bare minimum. Sharing a room? No way! Exclusive? Pay me very, very well!
Shiloh is so cute, I'm glad he is fitting into the family, Gigi will come around, we started out on the same foot (paw) a few years ago and now they are inseprable.
On teaching, "touche"
I've seen the moo cards and they are so cute! I saw some really cute holders for the moo cards at etsy.
Annie
I was very surprised by the absence of "big name" teachers at TNNA in January. I was hoping to finally catch a class from you! At a minimum I'm looking forward to your being a part of the Mile High Knitting conference in 2008.
Thanks for your thoughtful post. I look forward to an honest, open, and productive discussion about this matter.
Diane
aka Northside Knitter
awwwww, cute Shiloh!
my meredith didn't like steven at first; she hissed at him for a week. now they play together and chase each other thru the house.
interesting that atticus is intrigued by the kitten...
hold out for what you're worth, and damn the exclusive clauses!
It is all choices, isn't it? You can choose where to teach, and the shops can choose their teachers. If the rules set by some shops are too stringent, they won't get any teachers at all. So that will cause change. And if all the teachers could get together and agree to a 'minimal' level of treatment, things would change too.
I'm a college professor, and I work wtih my colleagues who teach in my sequence area to agree to what we will and won't accept and to stick to it (the sticking to it is the hardest part). I realize that your situation is different, but having a support system is always a help.
Shiloh looks like my Bobo when he was a baby!
As for teaching... I think you're right to say no to #2. Part of negotiating a deal is making sure everyone can live with the compromises reached within said deal. You're not happy, so it's better to pass on that opportunity. You can always try again another time...
As for standard contracts... I have no idea what would work best (since I don't teach knitting). Any business people out there with insights? Any union people out there? Financial planners? I'm looking forward to reading other people's opinions on this.
Thanks for sharing. I always find it interesting when people talk about their behind the scenes in their jobs no matter what the jobs are. Had never really thought about that aspect of your career before. Sadden for the knitters that will not have the chance to spend time with you. I took two of your classes at the Atlanta Sewing Expo and you are an excellent instructor. I'm hoping you will be able to come back to Atlanta and teach at Knitch sometime in 2008.
As for Atticus and Shiloh, love that photo!
I totally 100%-right on-amen agree to all of that. I would love a standard contract for knitting teachers. I think we should start bugging CYCA about one, since they have that teacher certification program.
At my current gig, I get paid hourly and don't have to cover any student or copying costs. Very nice. Problem is, they're the Art Center, not a yarn shop, so I can't join TNNA. Stupid, huh? I was thinking of getting the Director to write a letter to go with my application, but I think they'd just reject it.
Oh, and our guild was wondering if you were going to be back in Michigan this year so we could get on your schedule. We pay well. ;)
Too bad for them! I think that you are being entirely reasonable, and I'm proud of you for sticking to your guns. I'm just waiting for the time you teach in the SF Bay area!
I agree with what you're saying but I'm going to bring up another subject which is, in a way a 'student rant'.
Annie, the following is not meant to be a critisism of you but I did have an unfortunate experience while trying to register for a class you were scheduled to teach through a yarn shop.
You were scheduled to teach three classes in one day. I had read your teaching schedule on your blog and phoned the yarn shop you were suppose to be teaching early - before they were taking registration. I was told to call back in a week or so since the person on the phone didn't even know what I was talking about. I live 90 miles from the yarn shop so my plan was to get my kids off to school, drive up to the yarn shop, take a class and be home later in the afternoon. When I finally phoned at the right time, to talk to the right person to register she wouldn't take my registration because she was holding all seats for people who wanted to take all three classes. She told me to phone back a few days before the day of the classes and if there were any left over seats then I could register. By that time I was so frustrated I never called back. If the owner wanted to have an all day seminar at her yarn shop why was it listed as three discreet classes?
In a way my complaint supports the idea of multiple shops in the same area paying you to teach. Different schedules and different yarn shops can accommodate students' schedules better. Unfortunately this one particular yarn shop was the only game in town so I guess the owner thought she could set up her own rules about class registration. I guess she was right. So I can echo your last sentence in your blog entry:
'one size doesn't fit all'
There may be more to the story behind the scenes (I don't know for sure but I'm guessing here...) ...perhaps there was a knitting group that met at the store. Perhaps the owner knew all her favorite customers were going to want to take the classes so she didn't want to 'waste seats' on out-of-towners who don't frequent her shop as often. Funny how politics can enter into something like trying to register for a knitting class at a yarn shop....
is this venue in ohio? i've heard a few things.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home